This topic contains 6 replies, has 5 voices, and was last updated by Ella 1 year ago.
9 August 2019 at 11:37 am #1948
Nina VicSRC Staff
What’s right about the current model of secondary schooling? What’s not working? What are some ways the government could improve the delivery and design?
Share your ideas here!
23 August 2019 at 8:41 am #1964
Is it just me, or is there way too much to get through in the school year? Theirs a whole curriculum that has been set for all year levels, but I find that theirs just not enough time if they wanted us to complete the whole curriculum. It’s one of the big reasons why a majority of schools don’t tick certain parts of the curriculum off, such as Civics and Citizenship, or they just through a bunch of subjects together and make it one very big one.
23 August 2019 at 8:01 pm #1972
Although there are quite a few flaws in the current education system, such as there being a large amount of content that is often rushed due to the inadequate amount of time (as James stated above), but there are positives too. I personally have enjoyed the continuous involvement of applying what we learnt in class to the real world, not only in math but in so many subjects, such as science, geography and history etc. There’s also a constant loop of feedback that really benefits the learning of students, but of course in previous years we have done that too.
26 August 2019 at 10:10 am #1979
Nina VicSRC Staff
Thanks for the replies! @The Positive Blossom, great to hear your school is doing such great work. Would you feel comfortable emailing us so we can find out more about your school as a case study for good practice? Thanks!
11 September 2019 at 9:15 am #2087
Nina VicSRC Staff
The Victorian Government is making changes to the General Assessment Test (GAT). From 2021 students will get a statement for employers to ‘prove’ their literacy and numeracy when applying for a job or if your boss asks for it.
“Explicit reporting of literacy and numeracy attainment will be introduced from 2021 to provide school leavers with clear and explicit information of their literacy and numeracy attainment.” (DET website, accessed 11/09/2019, https://www.education.vic.gov.au/school/teachers/teachingresources/discipline/english/Pages/litnumstrategy.aspx)
VCAL and VCE students will both take the test and receive a statement to say whether they’ve ‘demonstrated’ or ‘exceeded’ literacy and numeracy standards.
The Minister for Education also proposed linking year 9 NAPLAN scores to a report linked to VCE results:
“He has proposed the creation of a new proficiency certificate tied to year 9 students’ NAPLAN results, which would reveal their proficiency in numeracy and literacy to would-be employers.” https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/link-year-9-naplan-results-to-jobs-to-boost-performance-minister-says-20190827-p52lcf.html
What do you think of these changes and proposed changes to secondary school assessments?
What will the impact be?
We want to hear your thoughts!
- This reply was modified 2 years ago by comms queen.
12 February 2020 at 10:02 am #2662
I think it is interesting that employers will ask for GAT literacy and numeracy test results. I agree that it can be a good way to see students’ general abilities. But the only disadvantage I see is that it adds more stress to students with VCE subjects and some students may not do as well because of the circumstances on the day of the testing (e.g. they might have a headache or the classroom may be loud) so perhaps if instead of one big test they did more (e.g. task-based) mini-tests it would be a fairer option?
27 May 2020 at 2:29 pm #3205
I strongly agree with James and ThePositiveBlossom;
My own opinion would also be that the current VCE curriculum is much too stressful and jam packed to be helpful or healthy for students. I think that students should be examined on the application of knowledge; not the knowledge itself, and that currently we place too much emphasis on getting the ;correct; answer when we should be looking at the meaning, thinking or working out behind it. The main problem is the rushed, pressure filled content that is crammed into too short a space of time.
15 September 2020 at 11:36 am #3394
Yeah, I agree with James, The PositiveBloom, Dariarioreo and Bee.
I think the idea in theory sounds great. However, leaving all the results to one day, is a huge added pressure for VCE students. Exams are already stressful enough. Also they are not considering what might be occurring at home, some students are young carers, students are living in a home with family violence, and more. I think our education needs to think of new ways of testing kids whilst still having the current methods in place too. It would be great if there was a way for students to create a student profile, something that records their community involvement, work experience, even life skills like cooking, street smarts, etc. I don’t think we should just be testing academia, many students are more practical and find the current system doesn’t suit them. I believe we need to be focusing on all the students skills not just academia. There isn’t just one kind of smart.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login